National Transportation Safety Board
Page 1
Copyright © 2016-2020 Alaska Survey Associates L.L.C., Eagle River (Anchorage), Alaska, USA
,
survey@alaskasurvey.net
Installed August 1, 2016, Last Revised November 1, 2020 - Hosted and maintained
by
Don Robertson
If
you’re
reading
this
for
information,
it
holds
a
lot
of
materials
that
can
help
you
learn
how
to
better
protect
yourself
from
accidents
and
injuries.
Knowing
how
the
NTSB
and
USCG
prosecute
marine
casualties
can
give
insights
on
how
to
implement
changes
in
your
vessel’s
management
systems
to
lessen
the
chances
that
your
vessel
is
involved
in
a
marine
casualty
in
the
first
place.
Bottom
line
is
to
prevent
accidents
and
injuries
at
all
cost
before
they
happen.
Unfortunately,
being
reactive
instead
of
proactive
is
the
normality
of
the
industry.
We
have
30
years
of
experience
working
with
safety
management
systems
and
how
they
direct
the
right
decision
and
mitigate
the
risk
that
cause
marine
casualties in the first place.
If
you’re
reading
this
because
you’ve
been
in
an
accident
or
marine
casualty,
the
first
advice
I
can
give
you that you need to do, and I’m not being rude or trying to be counterproductive but,
“Shut Your Mouth, Shut Your Mouth, Shut Your Mouth”
Call me immediately at 907-360-2145 Time is critical!!
Do not say anything to the USCG, NTSB, local law enforcement or any government agency. Very
politely say, “I will cooperate but I need to talk to my attorney first”. All questions legally should stop.
You have rights. What you tell NTSB can be used against you in court by the USCG and all government
agencies. It will become public record and if there is a civil suit in the future, the plaintiff’s counsel can
use these statements after any criminal proceeding to support their civil litigation against you.
There may have been an accident on your vessel. You’ve been hit, or you have had a lawsuit due to a
latent defect of equipment on board. It does not fit the criteria for the NTSB or USCG to investigate.
However, the litigation could make a substantial impact on your company employees well being
reputation, revenue. We review all evidence and even though it’s not a NTSB report, we use the same
techniques of the NTSB. Through our experience we find the root cause and protect your interest. We
work with your attorney, so they have the technical data they need to ask the right questions and protect
your interest.
What we do is buffer you from these agencies and media. You have a personnel and emotional interest in
the accident or catastrophic event that has brought on the investigation. Energy is high, emotions are
higher. Everything you say, “Can and will be held against you”. You’ve heard this before right? Often
just minutes after the accident or catastrophic event occurred, the investigation process has already
started. To be honest, its starts months before the accident because they will subpoena records. They
already have a mountain of evidence on day one. We work with you and your attorney. When the NTSB
or USCG looks at evidence they process it meticulously. I’ve been to the same school, I know their
techniques, methods and methodology, so I know how their thinking when they ask you for documents,
let there be no mistake about it, its evidence. When they ask for personnel records, training records, hour
cards, fuel records, maintenance records, equipment list and medical records their building the
foundation for cause that can be used in a criminal and civil case against you in the future.
The media might get you at 3 in the morning or 3 in the afternoon at the office and their telling you that
your boat is missing or is on fire. What you say at that moment will forever be achieved. What is said on
the radio, phone, recorded messages, text messages and log entries everything are admissible evidence.
Statements given or not given are crucial.
Here is an example. Your factory processor just went aground. They come to you at your office at 1500
on Friday afternoon and inform you of the following; The “FV Pay it Back” just spilled 100,000 usg of
fuel, next to a sea lion rookery, 25 people are missing and it’s been reported that a couple of the crew
gave statements and sent texts and put on social media after being recovered that a abandon ship drill
wasn’t conducted prior to getting underway, they say there wasn’t enough life jackets for everyone and
no one knew how to launch the life rafts.
You say; “This doesn’t surprise me, they must have been drunk when they left, that worthless captain,
I’ve had problems with him taking short cuts and he did us a favor, a few less sea lions wouldn’t hurt.”
What should have been said;
1. We’re doing everything for the safety and well-being of the recovered crew.
2. We’ve arranged for medical attention for anyone who needs it.
3. We’re working with the USCG in searching for all missing crew
4. We’re contacting the families of all crew members and providing information as it becomes available
5. We’re working with the USCG to lessen any effects of the spill and have
begun steps for the immediate clean up; stopping all fuel from
contaminating the environment and the sea lion population.
5. Then when the media ask a question to draw you away, you say the
above again in the same order. PERIOD.
I’m often asked how the NTSB chooses which marine accidents to
investigate and what role the U.S. Coast Guard (USCG) plays in our
investigations. The NTSB has specific authority under the United States
Code and Code of Federal Regulations to investigate “major marine casualties.” These are accidents
involving vessels that result in one or more of the following:
•
The loss of six or more lives.
•
The loss of a mechanically propelled vessel of 100 or more gross tons.
•
Property damage initially estimated as $500,000 or more.
•
Serious threat, as determined by the USCG commandant and concurred with by the NTSB
chairman, to life, property, or the environment by hazardous materials.
Their authority to investigate covers major marine accidents on U.S. waters or those involving U.S.-
flagged vessels worldwide. NTSB also have the authority to investigate casualties involving public
(owned by the U.S.) and nonpublic vessels. In these casualties the threshold is defined by at least one
fatality or damages of $75,000 or greater.
So, where does the USCG fit in? The USCG conducts preliminary investigations of all marine accidents,
then notifies NTSB when an accident qualifies as a major marine casualty. Unlike in other modes of
transportation, such as aviation, where the NTSB leads the investigation, the USCG typically takes the
lead in marine casualty investigations. Under a memorandum of understanding (MOU) between the
NTSB and USCG, however, the NTSB may become the lead federal agency for the investigation,
depending on the circumstances. This may occur when there is a significant marine accident that is a
subset of a major marine casualty and is defined in the MOU as the following: